Before the Devil Knows You're Dead
Brief Synopsis
Cast & Crew
Sidney Lumet
Steve Swanson
Ethan Hawke
Amy Ryan
Megan Byrne
Meredith Patterson
Film Details
Technical Specs
Synopsis
Andy, an overextended broker, lures his younger brother, Hank, into a larcenous scheme: the pair will rob a suburban mom-and-pop jewelry store that appears to be the quintessential easy target. The problem is, the store owners are Andy and Hank's actual mom and pop and, when the seemingly perfect crime goes awry, the damage lands right at their doorstep.
Director
![](https://prod-images.tcm.com/Master-Profile-Images/SidneyLumet.jpg?imwidth=188&height=141)
Sidney Lumet
Cast
Steve Swanson
Ethan Hawke
Amy Ryan
Megan Byrne
Meredith Patterson
John Knox
Michael Shannon
Blaine Horton
Patrick G Burns
Keith Davis
James Lally
Lee Wilkof
Marisa Tomei
![](https://prod-images.tcm.com/Master-Profile-Images/AlbertFinney.jpg?imwidth=188&height=141)
Albert Finney
Sarah Livingston
Arija Bareikis
Rosemary Harris
BrÃan O'byrne
Mateo Gomez
Myra Lucretia Taylor
![](https://prod-images.tcm.com/Master-Profile-Images/PhilipSeymourHoffman.87596.jpg?imwidth=188&height=141)
Philip Seymour Hoffman
Diane Bradley
Marcia Jean Kurtz
Josh Mowery
![](https://prod-images.tcm.com/Master-Profile-Images/LeonardoCimino.34486.jpg?imwidth=188&height=141)
Leonardo Cimino
Aleksa Palladino
Sakina Jaffrey
Damon Gupton
Alice Spivak
Jordan Gelber
Paul Butler
Adrian Martinez
Guy Fortt
Anita Sklar
Richard K Lublin
Tom Zolandz
Bob Colletti
Natalie Gold
Chris Chalk
Crew
Arlynn Abseck
G. A. Aguilar
Tom Allen
Belle Avery
Jane Barclay
Jeffrey Baron
Wesley Battle
Alexandra Bell
David Bergstein
Abigail Zealey Bess
Frymi Biedak
Carter Burwell
Carter Burwell
Carter Burwell
John Canavan
John Cenatiempo
Michael Cerenzie
Lindsay D. Chag
Rachel Chancey
Austin Chick
Austin Chick
Daniel B Cone
David Conelli
Joel Corenman
Darren Coverdale
Carol Cuddy
Carol Cuddy
Howard Davidson
Gregg Davis
Jerry Deblau
Angelo Digiacomo
Kenneth Dodd
Christopher Dolan
Alvaro Donado
Daniel Dougherty
Ann Edgeworth
Glen Engels
Nicole Evangelista
Michael Farrow
Robert Fernandez
Tony Finno
David Fischer
Jeong-hwa Fonklasrud
Rafael M Foraguada
Ron Fortunato
Jason Fritz
Ken Fundus
Joe Gawler
Chris Gibson
Andrew J Gilbert
Kevin Gilligan
Paula Gilmore
William S. Gilmore Jr.
Alexander Gorodetsky
Richard Guinness
James Hale
Kevin Hall
Gregg Harris
Will Hart
Wayne Herndon
Janette Jensen Hoffman
James Hook
Lilith Jacobs
Lilith Jacobs
Meredith Jacobson-marciano
Edma Jadan
Jason Kadlec
Marissa Kaplan
Billy Kerwick
Steve Kirshoff
Michael Kisur
Michael Kisur
Eli Klein
Thomas Kodros
Steve Koester
Denny Kortze
George Kousoulides
Jennifer Lame
Amy Lauritsen
Jim Lavin
Hannah Leader
Diane Lederman
Wing Lee
Eric Leigh
Abby Levine
Christopher Lewis
Ellen Lewis
Jessica Lichtner
Jennifer Lilly
Constantine Limberis
Brian Linse
Sidney Lumet
Bruce Maccallum
Cisco Marcial
Tracy Martin
Kelly Masterson
Jeffry Melnick
Adam Miller
James V Miller
Fred Milstein
Richard T Mitchell
Jerad Molkenthin
Chris Newman
Quang Nguyen
Tina Nigro
Heather Norton
Christopher A. Nowak
Gene O'neill
Steven Oppenheim
Glen Pangione
Chris Ann Pappas
Sandra Park
Dean Parker
Paul Parmar
Dave Paterson
Dave Paterson
Ralph Pellegrini
Guy Pham
Brent Poleski
Patricia Porter
Mary Ellen Porto
Frank Proscia
Joseph Proscia
Kate Quinlan
Patricia Regan
Joseph Reidy
Peter Reniers
Stephanie Rogers
Jeffrey Rollins
Mark Rozzo
Kelly Rutkowski
Lonnie Rutledge
Lonnie Rutledge
Beth M Schniebolk
Keith Siglinger
Diana Sikes
John Silvestri
Kelly Solomon
Brooke Stanford
Andrew D Stocker
Daniel Strol
Tom Swartwout
Nick Thomason
Joseph Viano
Damian Volpe
Jamie Waxman
Jeff Waxman
Warren Weberg
Patty Willett
Sam Zaharis
Christopher Ziter
Film Details
Technical Specs
Articles
Before the Devil Knows You're Dead - BEFORE THE DEVIL KNOWS YOU'RE DEAD - Sidney Lumet's Overlooked 2007 Noir on DVD
Synopsis (no spoilers): To fund his heroin habit, real estate finance manager Andy Hanson (Phillip Seymour Hoffman) has been stealing from his company. An upcoming audit forces him to extreme measures. Andy cons his younger brother Henry (Ethan Hawke) into robbing the little jewelry store owned by their parents Charles and Nanette (Albert Finney & Rosemary Harris). Henry can't keep up alimony payments to his ex-wife Martha (Amy Ryan of Gone Baby Gone) and suffers from low self-esteem, a problem that Andy exploits to coax Henry into pulling off the robbery on his own, on a Saturday when neither Mom nor Dad will be in the store. But Henry chickens out and secretly enlists a tough-guy pal, Bobby Lasorda (Brian F. O'Byrne of Bug). Without being asked, Bobby brings a gun along on the job ...
An engaging ensemble film, Before the Devil Knows You're Dead is a genuine neo-noir in that it goes beyond style to engage with the noir concerns of culpability and fate. The resentments and failings between the brothers congeal into a classic trap that begins with a 'simple' crime and ends in almost total ruin.
Siblings Andy and Henry Hanson's shameful adventure is far from glamorous. They're just sympathetic enough to hold our interest, even while making disastrous personal decisions. Andy is already a thief and a casual junkie. His expensive habit makes him impotent, and he compensates with his puzzled wife Gina (Marisa Tomei) with promises of an escape to paradise in Brazil. Sensing that something's up, Gina hates Andy all the more for not leveling with her -- she knows, for instance, that Brazil has no extradition treaty with the United States.
Andy is also enough of an egotist to think that he can manipulate his weak brother Henry, a man who can't face his responsibilities. Henry crumbles when he can't come up with the promised money to send his spoiled nine year-old daughter to see The Lion King on stage. Henry and Gina are keeping an even worse secret from Andy. That these foolish brothers think they can pull off a perfect 'all in the family' crime all but guarantees that they'll end up in the soup.
The disastrously unsuccessful robbery is only the first stop in a grueling chain of personal tragedies. Wracked with guilt, Andy and Henry only add to their problems. Andy still faces an audit that will surely send him to jail; he's avoiding phone calls from work. Henry is soon cornered by Bobby Lasorda's wife Chris and brother in-law Dex (Aleksa Palladino & Michael Shannon), who expect cash in exchange for their silence. Hovering above both boys is their father Charles, a good man traumatized and angered by what's happened (it would be unfair to explain why) to the point that he's smashing police cars because the cops won't investigate the robbery further.
Plaudits are in order for first time screenwriter Kelly Masterson, who arranges his narrative in a staggered series of out-of-sequence bites. The popular Pulp Fiction spawned a rash of movies that splinter time, more often than not to disguise pedestrian narratives by withholding information or creating a 'puzzle' that the viewer must assemble for themselves. The script does fool us a couple of times, as when it initially hides the identity of Henry's hooded accomplice. But Masterson and director Lumet employ the fractured format to stay focused on a particular character through complicated situations. We see a number of scenes twice, from differing points of view. Gina receives and curtails a cell phone call in the middle of a funeral reception. Only later do we see who is calling, when part of the scene replays from a different point of view.
The best thing about Before the Devil Knows You're Dead is that director Lumet doesn't allow the story extremes to get out of hand. This isn't the old noir film Quicksand, in which a purloined $20 bill snowballs into an unlikely manhunt for kidnapping and murder. Andy and Henry sink into trouble in carefully measured steps, so that when people are finally pointing guns at each other, nothing seems silly. In fact, we don't see how it could have turned out any other way. The film balances aberrant character behavior with the necessities of living: when the elderly Charles Hanson pursues his own kin with murder on his mind, he still has to find a parking space.
Sidney Lumet has a fine record with films about crime and personal relationships. His earlier Family Business assembles the unlikely team of Sean Connery, Matthew Broderick and Dustin Hoffman. Before the Devil Knows You're Dead has little comedy and isn't built on star power, but it's a solid entertainment.
Phillip Seymour Hoffman plays a despicable man that we nevertheless recognize as real, and Ethan Hawke's loser hero reveals a new layer of weakness every time he falls apart. Albert Finney is masterful as a family man in the throes of despair, who must face a greater horror when he discovers exactly what has own son has done. Marisa Tomei begins the movie with a series of (necessary?) nude sex scenes that perhaps point to her contentious position between the two brothers. She has a good scene walking out on Andy, and becoming enraged when he doesn't react.
The estimable Rosemary Harris is only on for a few minutes. Amy Ryan's bitter ex-wife takes pleasure in watching Henry squirm. Aleksa Palladino, Michael Shannon and Bobby Lasorda form another unfortunate family unit that has the misfortune to deal with the Hansons. And the impressive Leonardo Cimino (Moonstruck, Dune) turns a bit part as a fence for stolen jewelry into a key role -- he alone seems to understand the evil that's ripped the Hanson family in half.
Image's disc of Before the Devil Knows You're Dead is a good-looking 1:85 enhanced widescreen encoding of a film shot on HD. Only a few bright exteriors give this away. Image is also releasing the film on Blu-ray disc; that version won't be for sale until May 6.
The disc is flush with extras. The energetic Sidney Lumet joins with Ethan Hawke and Phillip Seymour Hoffman for a friendly commentary track that gets a tad sparse by the end but still carries more than its share of interesting observations. A lengthy making-of featurette examines the film from all sides and gives a full picture of Lumet's shoot on the New York streets. The highly organized director works out of a plain office, believes in full rehearsals and shoots quickly. He loves HD because it allows him to move that much faster, often finishing his day's work early. The actors clearly adore him, knowing that working on a Lumet film is a special privilege.
The package rounds off with a good trailer, formatted for an even wider 2:35 aspect ratio. Before the Devil Knows You're Dead deserves all the attention it can get; thriller fans shouldn't miss it.
To order Before the Devil Knows You're Dead, go to TCM Shopping
by Glenn Erickson
![Before The Devil Knows You're Dead - Before The Devil Knows You're Dead - Sidney Lumet's Overlooked 2007 Noir On Dvd](https://prod-images.tcm.com/img/film-participant-detail/Featured-Artilce_Placeholder.png)
Before the Devil Knows You're Dead - BEFORE THE DEVIL KNOWS YOU'RE DEAD - Sidney Lumet's Overlooked 2007 Noir on DVD
Quotes
Trivia
Miscellaneous Notes
Winner of the 2007 award for Best Ensemble Cast by the Boston Society of Film Critics (BSFC).
Winner of the 2007 award for Best Supporting Actress (Amy Ryan) by the Los Angeles Film Critics Association (LAFCA).
Released in United States Fall October 26, 2007
Released in United States November 2, 2007
Released in United States on Video April 15, 2008
Released in United States 2007
Released in United States October 2007
Shown at Deauville Festival of American Cinema (Premiere) August 31-September 9, 2007.
Shown at New York Film Festival September 28-October 14, 2007.
Shown at Vancouver International Film Festival (Cinema of Our Time) September 27-October 12, 2007.
Shown at Chicago International Film Festival (World Cinema) October 4-17, 2007.
Shown at Hamptons International Film Festival (Spotlight) October 17-21, 2007.
Shown at Rome Film Festival (Cinema 2007/Special Event) October 18-27, 2007.
Released in United States Fall October 26, 2007 (NY, LA)
Released in United States November 2, 2007 (Los Angeles)
Released in United States on Video April 15, 2008
Released in United States 2007 (Shown at Deauville Festival of American Cinema (Premiere) August 31-September 9, 2007.)
Released in United States 2007 (Shown at New York Film Festival September 28-October 14, 2007.)
Voted one of the 10 best films of 2007 by the American Film Institute (AFI).
Released in United States 2007 (Shown at Vancouver International Film Festival (Cinema of Our Time) September 27-October 12, 2007.)
Released in United States October 2007 (Shown at Chicago International Film Festival (World Cinema) October 4-17, 2007.)
Released in United States October 2007 (Shown at Hamptons International Film Festival (Spotlight) October 17-21, 2007.)
Released in United States October 2007 (Shown at Rome Film Festival (Cinema 2007/Special Event) October 18-27, 2007.)