The Bitter Tea of General Yen
Sure enough, Columbia Pictures and director Frank Capra found themselves in hot water. "Seeing a Chinaman attempting to romance with a pretty and supposedly decent young American white woman," predicted Variety reviewer Sam Shain, "is bound to provoke adverse reaction." How true. Capra claimed in his memoir, The Name Above the Title, that the picture lost money because it "was banned in Great Britain and in British Commonwealth countries due to the shocking implications of a love affair between a yellow man and a white woman." While that isn't true - the Commonwealth censors passed the picture, as did the British censors after a few cuts - The Bitter Tea of General Yen definitely lost money, despite Columbia's energetic publicity campaign for the million-dollar production, its most expensive to date, and according to a Variety report, the "nucleus" around which the studio's entire 1933 slate would be marketed. "Drawn together by fate," the ads trumpeted with an uneasy blend of candor and sensationalism, "a man of the East...a woman of the West...their forbidden love wrecked an empire."
Another loser was Radio City Music Hall, the largest movie theater in the West or East, where Capra's melodrama had its New York premiere on January 11, 1933, the same day it debuted in other large cities. The ritzy and enormous Music Hall had opened for business just two weeks earlier as a vaudeville house, then quickly introduced a policy of film showings with tickets cheap enough for Depression audiences to afford. The Bitter Tea of General Yen was the first movie to play there; it was scheduled for a minimum two-week run, but the theater yanked it after eight days and $80,000 in grosses, despite the certainty of a $20,000 loss on its $100,000 rental fee. In his memoir, Capra proudly recalls that "it was chosen as the film to open Radio City Music Hall," omitting its less-than-glorious performance on the occasion. He certainly considered the movie to be big and bold enough for the world's biggest and boldest movie house; in his book American Vision: The Films of Frank Capra, critic Raymond Carney makes the fascinating point that Yen's palace actually resembles one of the great '30s picture palaces, which tried to "create a world of cinematic consciousness that could stand as an alternative to the world outside the film."
Based on a story by Grace Zaring Stone, which Capra called a "strangely poetic romance," The Bitter Tea of General Yen begins in war-torn Shanghai, where an aptly named missionary, the Rev. Dr. Bob Strife, is taking an afternoon off from saving souls to marry Megan, his childhood sweetheart. But duty calls - several children are stranded in an imperiled orphanage, and Bob rushes off to save them before the ceremony starts, taking Megan along for the ride. The situation is more chaotic than he bargained for, and when he's knocked unconscious by a rioting mob, Megan gets rescued by General Yen, who spirits her away, puts her up in his summer palace, and does what he can to woo and win her. Megan is initially charmed by the tall, handsome officer, who speaks all sorts of languages and carries himself the way she imagines an emperor would. We know better, since the screenplay has informed us of his ruthless and cold-blooded side, and Megan wises up when she realizes he's about to kill Mah-Li, his Chinese mistress, for cheating on him with Captain Li, his aide. It turns out the mistress is more heartless than the general, though, and when Yen selflessly decides to let her live, Megan starts falling for him. The climax arrives when she's forced to acknowledge her un-Christian hypocrisy in benefiting from his generosity and protection while staving off the warmth and affection he's held out to her. She agrees to stay by his side, but realizing that she'll never love him of her own free will, Yen prepares to drink a cup of poisoned tea. This doesn't happen in the novel, where Yen's enemies kill him as he helps Megan get to safety. In the original draft of the screenplay, according to critic Joseph McBride, he tosses the tea away when Megan yields to him. Capra devised the film's actual ending, wherein Yen drinks the tea and dies as Megan looks innocently on. This is followed by a brief coda, which shows Megan heading back to Bob but clearly daydreaming, wordlessly and tenderly, about the remarkable general she's left behind.
The Bitter Tea of General Yen was the fourth picture in four years directed by Capra with Stanwyck as the star; she teamed with him again for Meet John Doe in 1941, but this was her last Columbia film. She handles her role with skill, gracefulness, and a lot of glamour, thanks partly to cinematographer Joseph Walker, who appreciated the movie's "pictorial possibilities" and spiced it up with portrait lenses and a diffusion device of his own design. As the other main character, Capra didn't want "a well-known star made up as an Oriental," but he had no problem with "a not-too-well-known Swedish actor" made up as one. Asther had the "impassive face" and "slightly pedantic" accent that Capra was looking for, so the make-up artist covered his upper eyelids with "skins" and clipped his eyelashes to a third of their normal length, and the wardrobe department decked him out in sumptuous Mandarin robes and a tall black skullcap. The result of these labors, not surprisingly, is a Hollywood stereotype: "On the screen," Capra enthuses in his memoir, "he looked strange - unfathomable." But it's visually stunning nonetheless, making Yen one of Capra's most memorable characters.
Like others connected with the picture, Stanwyck blamed its poor box-office showing on racist backlash. McBride quotes her as saying, "The women's clubs came out very strongly against it....I was so shocked. [Such a reaction] never occurred to me, and I don't think it occurred to Mr. Capra when we were doing it." Maybe not, but Capra was cruising for an Oscar® at this point in his career, and he saw the project as "Art with a capital A," risky and offbeat enough to convince the Academy that it was an act of culture as well as commerce. Although it suffered a shut-out from the Oscar® race, Capra kept up his faith in it, saying a few years later that it "has more real movie in it than any other I did." He was right. For all its racial stereotyping and insensitive dialogue, The Bitter Tea of General Yen endows Yen with an outward charisma and inward dignity that never quit, and his final exit from the story is as emotionally rich as anything Capra ever crafted. Stanwyck also shines in what one commentator calls, with some exaggeration, "the only art film" she ever made. The movie and its compelling lead performances deserve a far wider audience than they've received.
Producer: Walter Wanger
Director: Frank R. Capra
Screenplay: Edward E. Paramore, Jr.; based on a story by Grace Zaring Stone
Cinematographer: Joseph Walker
Film Editing: Edward Curtiss
Music: W. Franke Harling
With: Barbara Stanwyck (Megan), Nils Asther (General Yen), Toshia Mori (Mah-Li), Walter Connolly (Jones), Gavin Gordon (Bob), Lucien Littlefield (Mr. Jacobson), Richard Loo (Captain Li), Helen Jerome Eddy (Miss Reed), Emmett Corrigan (Bishop Harkness).
BW-87m.
by David Sterritt
SOURCES:
Starring Miss Barbara Stanwyck by Ella Smith (Crown Publishers)
Frank Capra: The Catastrophe of Success by Joseph McBride (Simon & Schuster)
The Films of Barbara Stanwyck by Homer Dickens (Citadel Press)
The Name Above the Title by Frank Capra (Random House)
