Withers first appeared in the novel The Penguin Pool Murder in 1931, the latest in a long line of elderly female detectives that dates back to Miss Amelia Butterworth, a character created by Anna Katherine Greene in 1898. She would be followed by Rachel Innes in Mary Roberts Rinehart's The Circular Staircase (1908) -- better known by its stage and film title, The Bat -- and Agatha Christie's Miss Marple, who made her first appearance just a year before Withers. Drawing on his background as a private detective, Palmer wrote novels and short stories about the character for more than two decades.
At the time RKO filmed The Penguin Pool Murder, they had the perfect Hildegarde Withers under contract, character actress Edna May Oliver, who had won acclaim for her supporting role in the Oscar®-winning Western Cimarron (1931). As her partner in crime solving they cast another veteran, James Gleason. Their affectionate sparring was so effective the studio even had them get married at the end. Director George Archainbaud kept the action moving briskly, as he would on the Western films and television series he would specialize in decades later. He also added an innovation that would remain unnoticed for years; several of the sets had ceilings prominently featured. In that, he anticipated Orson Welles' work on Citizen Kane (1941) by almost ten years.
The Penguin Pool Murder did well enough to inspire a second sequel, Murder on the Blackboard (1934), with the same stars, director and writer two years later. Deciding that Withers and Piper worked best as friendly antagonists, studio executives decided to disregard their marriage at the end of the previous feature. Oliver would star in one more Withers film, Murder on a Honeymoon (1935), with Gleason but without Archainbaud. When she left RKO later that year, the studio would try to keep things going first with Helen Broderick and then Zasu Pitts in the lead. But neither was as perfectly cast as Oliver, and the series died after only six films. That hardly marked the end of the road for Withers, however. MGM adapted Once Upon a Train, co-written by Palmer and Craig Rice to team Withers with Rice's hard-drinking lawyer detective John Malone, in 1951. But they transformed the schoolteacher sleuth into a Montana housewife played by Marjorie Main for Mrs. O'Malley and Mr. Malone. In 1971, ABC would produce A Very Missing Person, a pilot for a Hildegarde Withers TV series starring Eve Arden, but decided not to pick up the project. Five years later, the character would put in her last screen appearance, in Neil Simon's private eye spoof Murder by Death (1976). This time she would be played by Estelle Winwood as a decrepit old woman cared for by Elsa Lanchester in a spoof of Agatha Christie's Miss Marple. None of these pretenders to the chalkboard could compare to the original, however. Whenever The Penguin Pool Murder airs on television, it attracts new members to its devoted cult of fans.
Producer: Kenneth Macgowan, David O. Selznick
Director: George Archainbaud
Screenplay: Willis Goldbeck
Based on a story by Lowell Brentano and the novel by Stuart Palmer
Cinematography: Henry Gerrard
Music: Max Steiner
Principal Cast: Edna May Oliver (Hildegarde Withers), Robert Armstrong (Barry Costello), James Gleason (Oscar Piper), Mae Clarke (Gwen Parker), Donald Cook (Philip Seymour), Edgar Kennedy (Donovan).
BW-66m.
by Frank Miller
